Costco has a strong presence in the U.S., with 584 locations nationwide and a global membership base of 123 million as of early 2023, according to Zippia. It’s no surprise, then, that 26% of Americans aged 18 to 29 report regularly shopping there—myself included!
As someone who frequently visits Costco, I spend endless hours navigating through their aisles to purchase everything from large quantities of snacks to sweet baked goods. But if you’re like me, you’ve probably noticed something heartbreaking: some of your favorite items just… disappear.
Costco has mastered the art of tempting us with amazing products only to take them away. These 12 unforgettable Costco classics continue to haunt our memories (and yes, I might have shed a tear over a few of these).
All-American Chocolate Cake
The seven-pound confection was a rich and decadent party in cake form that gained fame on social media, particularly on Instagram. The item disappeared in 2020, which left a frosting-shaped void in our hearts.
An active Change.org petition, which has garnered 9,000 signatures, continues to call for the return of a discontinued Costco item. Every time someone attempts to make the cake at home, the result never measures up to the original. The smaller version is available, but it simply doesn’t contain enough chocolate.
Polish Hot Dog
In 2018, Costco discontinued this cherished sausage, citing a shift toward healthier options. This sparked fan outrage. Unlike the milder all-beef version, the Polish dog had a smoky snap that was unmistakable.
A Change.org petition to bring back the Polish Hot Dog garnered over 16,500 signatures, demonstrating that fans were emotionally attached to the product. Members continue to inquire at the store counter about its potential return. Sadly, this one’s likely gone for good.
Combo Pizza (Food Court)
The beloved pizza slice was an exciting blend of pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions, and mushrooms, which created a chaotic yet delightful combination. Costco’s combo pizza was priced at $9.95 for a whole 18-inch pizza or $1.99 per slice before it was discontinued in 2020.
The combo pizza remains absent from Costco’s offerings despite Reddit users continuing to discuss it and speculate about a potential frozen release. The loss of this pizza has created one of the most painful heartbreaks for food court enthusiasts.
Barbecue Beef Brisket Sandwich
The food court once featured this smoky meat sandwich as an undiscovered treasure, introduced in 2013. The well-seasoned brisket paired with tangy barbecue sauce made customers feel like they were getting a ten-dollar sandwich for just pennies. Through cost-cutting decisions, it vanished from menus in 2020.
Loyal customers continue to praise it in online communities, where they refer to it as “heaven on Earth.” Costco has not officially announced any plans to bring back the dessert, yet people continue to fantasize about eating it for the first time.
Hand‑Dipped Ice Cream Bar (with Almonds)
There was just something magical about these creamy bars dunked in chocolate and rolled in almonds. This heavenly treat cost just $1.50—a deal that I still reminisce about.
The discontinuation happened in 2013, but we haven’t yet fully moved on from it. The exact reason for its removal isn’t officially confirmed, but speculation points to tariffs and rising costs of dairy and almonds, with others citing that the bars were labor-intensive.
The “I remember when…” stories about that glorious crunch circulate frequently among Redditors. Costco has yet to respond to the monthly petitions and nostalgic pleas from fans. We’ll have to make do with regular soft serve until they return (sigh).
Cinnamon Sugar Pretzels
These delightful, fluffy snacks felt like cozy pillows sprinkled with happiness itself. They continued as a seasonal favorite for many years before their sudden and unexplained disappearance over a decade ago. Customers were left without any formal farewell announcement or official reason when they vanished.
A few members have reported seeing these treats during selective runs, but the sightings happen sporadically. When people reference “Costco pretzels,” they mean this specific treat.
Kirkland Chocolate Chips
The semi-sweet Kirkland Chocolate Chips reached cult status among expert bakers. Costco switched to Nestlé chips in 2024 due to rising cocoa prices (nearly 200% higher than the previous year), but the switch didn’t go unnoticed.
The taste and certified kosher parve status made these items highly sought after by fans. People hoarded bags to prepare for the possible permanent disappearance of Costco Chocolate Chips. The quiet end of these cookies reduced the magic of many cookie jars.
Kirkland Frozen Four‑Cheese Ravioli
These ravioli were pasta-night perfection, stuffed with ricotta cheese, Asiago, Parmesan, and Grana Padano. The simplicity of preparation, combined with their rich taste, turned them into a top choice for families on weekday evenings.
The frozen cheese-filled ravioli disappeared from the shelves in late 2023, and Costco customers have not seen them return since then. Costco currently sells spinach and butternut squash alternatives, although they fail to match the original. Cheese enthusiasts among us continue to struggle with this loss.
Kirkland Turkey Burgers
These turkey burgers were a lean, protein-packed freezer staple popular among many shoppers. Each patty boasted 35 grams of protein and just 200 calories, making them a go-to for health-conscious shoppers. They disappeared from shelves in 2018 without any specified alternative available.
People appreciated the simple ingredients and no-fuss cooking style. Although several third-party brands have gained attention, none have successfully replaced the original product. Costco regular customers are likely to request the return of their beloved turkey burgers.
Roasted Garlic Parmesan Bread
This loaf has earned legendary status due to its combination of a crispy crust, a soft interior, and a savory taste profile. The bakery always displayed it fresh, and the aroma was powerful enough to pull customers from two aisles away. After the product was discontinued, customers repeatedly requested its return to the employees.
Occasionally it would pop up for a week or two—then disappear like a cheesy phantom. Costco keeps its recipe secret, but our sense of smell recalls it vividly.
Pulmuone Chicken Potstickers
Quick, delicious, and freezer-friendly, these potstickers were a favorite for busy weeknights. Their flavor quality and superior filling received frequent commendations. The potstickers disappeared from store shelves at some point, and their fans started mourning their absence.
Social media threads still ask, “Has anyone seen them lately?” Spoiler: they haven’t—and the freezer aisle feels a bit colder without them.
Kirkland Organic Chocolate Banana Almond Beverage
The creamy beverage offered plant-based enthusiasts a sweet and satisfying shelf-stable delight. The beverage developed a dedicated fan base among smoothie enthusiasts and those who prefer dairy-free diets.
Then, one day, it was just… gone. No press release, no official farewell—just vanished from the beverage section. Fans throughout the U.S. are holding out hope for its unexpected reappearance. In fact, based on a report by Warehouse Wanderer, it quietly returned to shelves at select Costco locations.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Costco Doesn’t Always Give Goodbyes—Just Ghostings. Many of these items didn’t get a farewell tour. The products disappeared overnight, leaving Costco members both puzzled and desperate for more. No memo, no warning—just heartbreak in bulk.
- Petitions, Reddit Threads, and Fan Meltdowns Are Real. The Polish hot dog and chocolate cake continue to evoke strong feelings among people. Numerous people have signed digital petitions and exchanged recipes in their attempt to recreate the magic. (Spoiler: it’s never the same.)
- Seasonal or “Quietly Discontinued” Doesn’t Mean Forgotten. Cinnamon pretzels and garlic bread reappear sporadically, which keeps our hope alive. Although substitutions were made for these products, their replacements never quite felt right.
- Costco’s Greatest Hits Weren’t Always Flashy, But They Were Loved. Weeknights became easier and tastier thanks to staples like plant-based drinks, frozen ravioli, and turkey burgers. And once they’re gone, they leave more than just shelf space—they leave a legacy.
Disclaimer – This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information. It is not intended to be professional advice.
How Total Beginners Are Building Wealth Fast in 2025—No Experience Needed
How Total Beginners Are Building Wealth Fast in 2025
I used to think investing was something you did after you were already rich. Like, you needed $10,000 in a suit pocket and a guy named Chad at some fancy firm who knew how to “diversify your portfolio.” Meanwhile, I was just trying to figure out how to stretch $43 to payday.
But a lot has changed. And fast. In 2025, building wealth doesn’t require a finance degree—or even a lot of money. The tools are simpler. The entry points are lower. And believe it or not, total beginners are stacking wins just by starting small and staying consistent.
Click here and let’s break down how.
12 Everyday Grocery Store Favorites Now Pack Banned Additives
Let me paint a picture. I was standing in the cereal aisle, scanning the shelves for my childhood favorite—those colorful little rings bursting with artificial fruit flavor. I hadn’t bought them in years, but nostalgia hit hard. Then I noticed something new on the label: “Now with no artificial dyes.”
12 Everyday Grocery Store Favorites Now Pack Banned Additives
