In recent years, comedians have found themselves walking a delicate line, balancing humor with the evolving sensitivities of modern audiences. “Woke culture,” often characterized by an increased awareness of social justice issues, has brought new expectations for how people should talk about gender, race, and identity, and it’s affecting comedy’s most foundational principle: the freedom to push boundaries.
As some comedians see it, these cultural shifts make it increasingly difficult to create material without fear of backlash. Here’s an exploration of how woke culture is impacting stand-up comedy, including quotes from comedians who have spoken out about these challenges.
The Impact of Woke Culture on Comedy
Comedy has long been an art form that defies convention, speaking truth to power and poking fun at society’s flaws. However, many comedians feel that woke culture’s emphasis on sensitivity restricts their ability to do this.
This Is Not Brand New
For instance, veteran comedian Jerry Seinfeld stated in a 2015 article in The Washington Post that college campuses, typically filled with young, “woke” audiences, are especially difficult places to perform. “They just want to use these words: ‘That’s racist;’ ‘That’s sexist;’ ‘That’s prejudiced,’” Seinfeld noted, adding that the hyper-sensitivity creates a tense environment for comics who traditionally rely on the freedom to explore controversial topics.
Comedy Should Not Be Censored
Dave Chappelle has also faced criticism for his edgy humor but remains steadfast in his approach, arguing that comedy should not be censored. In his 2021 Netflix special “The Closer,” Chappelle addresses this tension directly, saying that he “refuses to bow to woke culture.” As Chappelle explains, he feels that woke audiences fail to grasp that “comedians are the last free speakers in society”.
A History of Edginess in Comedy
Comedy has always pushed boundaries. From Lenny Bruce to Richard Pryor, comedians have used their platforms to address controversial topics and, in many cases, to challenge societal norms. As stand-up comic Jim Norton explained in an interview with Vulture, “Good comedy doesn’t always make people feel comfortable. It’s supposed to be challenging.” However, Norton observes that in the current climate, audiences often see edgy humor as offensive rather than thought-provoking, creating a clash between comedy’s traditional role and the demands of modern, “woke” sensibilities.
Censorship vs. Free Speech: Comedians Speak Out
For comedians, one of the greatest challenges presented by woke culture is the risk of censorship and the constant potential for backlash. As Bill Burr expressed in a podcast interview with Joe Rogan, “Everyone’s so quick to cancel you over something they might disagree with.” Burr, known for his unapologetic style, argues that this culture makes comedians second-guess themselves, restricting the creative freedom that comedy depends on.
From Joe Rogan to John Cleese
Joe Rogan, himself no stranger to controversy, has also commented on the effect of woke culture on comedy. Rogan believes that this movement creates a “mob mentality” that doesn’t allow for nuance or context in comedy. He stated on his own podcast that “Woke culture wants to strip comedy of its edge and its freedom to explore taboos.” For Rogan, this lack of freedom fundamentally changes the nature of stand-up comedy.
Impeding Creative Risk Taking
John Cleese has been vocal about how “wokeness” impacts creativity and humor. He explained that constant concern over offending audiences’ stifles comedians’ ability to be creative. Cleese argues that comedy thrives in an atmosphere of freedom but woke culture pressures comedians into “safe areas” and limits their range of expression. He discussed this in a conversation at FreedomFest, describing how “checking everything” before saying it makes it challenging for comedians to take creative risks.
The Shift in Audience Expectations
The expectations of audiences have also changed, with many younger fans expecting comedians to uphold certain moral standards or avoid potentially offensive material. Comedian Ricky Gervais has spoken about how audience sensitivities have evolved, often detracting from the humor itself.
Everyone Is Allowed To Offend
In a 2022 interview in The Independent, Gervais stated being able to offend in comedy is a “good system”. “Everyone is allowed to offend, and everyone is allowed to be offended,” commented the comedian. Gervais argues that audiences have shifted from simply wanting to laugh to critiquing the morality of the joke itself, which he feels limits the type of material comedians can produce.
Perfection Not Attainable
This perspective is echoed by comedian Kevin Hart, who has faced backlash for past jokes and remarks, leading to the cancellation of his hosting gig at the 2019 Oscars. Hart has noted that no one is perfect, and the expectation that comedians should be is just unrealistic. Hart’s view underscores the difficulties comedians face in appealing to audiences that demand moral perfection.
Humanity vs Theory
On the other hand, Judd Apatow, who has produced Hart, went on record in Vanity Fair to discuss the nuances of being a comedian, how they evolve. Should we cancel those who have performed jokes in the past that would not be “acceptable” now? “…sometimes your humanity is more important than some theory of comedy. You know what? I think you are interesting, and I don’t think you should be kicked while you’re down.”
Navigating Cancel Culture
“Cancel culture” is another aspect of woke culture that influences comedians. Many worry that a single joke, taken out of context, could lead to career-ending consequences. According to Sarah Silverman, comedians are constantly “walking on eggshells” due to fear of being canceled. In a GQ interview, Silverman discusses that she believes there is no forgiveness anymore. People are judged forever based on things that don’t reflect who they are today. This sentiment captures the anxiety many comedians feel about their past and present material in a time when one misstep can have lasting consequences.
How Not To Lose Your Voice
Patton Oswalt, another veteran comedian, has a more nuanced view of woke culture’s impact. In an interview with Vanity Fair, Oswalt acknowledged that while some sensitivity is warranted, it’s challenging for comics to “navigate the current climate without losing their voice.” He suggests that while comedians can adapt to changing social standards, it’s important not to lose sight of comedy’s purpose, which is often to push boundaries and provoke thought.
Does Woke Culture Affect How Comedians Are Booked?
Yes. The perspective of comedy club bookers, promoters, and festival organizers adds a valuable angle to the discussion on how woke culture impacts comedy. Bookers and promoters increasingly find themselves navigating the complexities of audience sensitivities and concerns over backlash, which affects which comedians they can book and the type of content they are willing to support.
Insights From Bookers
- Paul Provenza, Host of ‘The Green Room’ and Comedy Festival Organizer, shared his views on the effects of woke culture in an interview with Quillette. He noted that the expectations of today’s audiences put comedians and bookers under pressure to cater to specific viewpoints, which he believes limits the diversity of voices in comedy. Provenza sees this as a significant departure from comedy’s role as a space for free expression and risk-taking.
- Al Martin, Owner of Broadway Comedy Club: Martin spoke to The New York Times about how woke culture affects bookings, saying, “There’s a constant worry about backlash. Bookers like me have to ask, ‘Is this joke or comedian going to offend someone?’ And that’s a tough position because comedy has always been about taking risks.”
These perspectives reflect how woke culture not only influences the performers but also creates challenges for those managing the business side of comedy. Bookers are increasingly concerned about balancing comedic expression with audience expectations, affecting who gets booked and what types of humor are accepted on stage.
The Future of Comedy in Woke Culture
Despite the challenges, some comedians believe that comedy can adapt to meet the demands of a more “woke” audience. Hasan Minhaj, known for his socio-political comedy, embraces the shift, arguing that “Woke culture forces comedians to work harder and be smarter with their jokes.”
In a 2019 interview with NPR, Minhaj noted that “Woke culture can be frustrating, but it’s also an opportunity to find fresh, creative ways to tackle issues.”
Similarly, Tiffany Haddish believes that adapting to woke culture is part of comedy’s evolution. In an interview with The New York Times, Haddish explains her perspective that it’s about knowing your audience and being respectful, but that doesn’t mean you can’t be funny. Haddish’s perspective suggests that while the current climate is challenging, comedians can still find ways to create impactful humor.
Final Thoughts: Can Comedy and Woke Culture Coexist?
While woke culture undoubtedly presents unique challenges for comedians, many argue that it’s not an entirely negative force. The evolving expectations encourage comics to reflect on their material and, in some cases, to be more thoughtful.
Yet, as Jerry Seinfeld, Dave Chappelle, and others have pointed out, the heart of comedy has always been to push boundaries—a task that’s increasingly difficult under the pressures of woke culture and cancel culture.
What Will Be Comedy’s Evolution?
The tension between comedy’s traditional role and the sensitivities of modern audiences suggests a complex future for stand-up. As comedian Whitney Cummings has stated, “Comedy has to evolve, but if we lose the freedom to speak openly, then we lose something essential about what makes stand-up such a powerful art form.”
How Hollywood Treats Older Women: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
Hollywood, as an industry, has long been a reflection of societal norms, shaping and being shaped by culture. Its portrayal and treatment of older women, however, often highlights some glaring disparities. While some advancements have been made, there remain deeply ingrained challenges. The treatment of older women in Hollywood can be summed up in three categories: the good, the bad, and the ugly.
READ: How Hollywood Treats Older Women: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
