Lifestyle | MSN Slideshow

12 common English sayings that make no sense

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our disclosure policy for details.

Have you ever stopped mid-sentence and realized half the things we say in English make absolutely no sense?

English is such a funny language—I learned that the hard way when I told my nephew to “break a leg” before his school play, and he looked at me like I’d completely lost it. I had to quickly explain that I wasn’t wishing him harm, just good luck (because somehow, that makes sense?). The phrase actually dates back to the 1920s and 1930s, appearing in old theatrical writings and memoirs.

One of the earliest mentions comes from Robert Wilson Lynd’s 1921 essay, where he explained that in horse racing, saying “good luck” was thought to bring bad luck, so people started saying, “May you break your leg!” instead. Moments like that make me realize how bizarre our sayings really are—you can “spill the beans,” “hit the hay,” and “hold your horses” all in one sentence, and no one even blinks.

Break a leg

Break a leg
Image Credit: Edmond Dantès via pexels

Why on earth would we wish injury on someone before they step on stage? Turns out, “break a leg” is theater slang from the early 20th century that actually means “good luck.”

The phrase may come from the idea of “breaking” into a bow by bending your leg after a performance. Still, if you tell your friend this before their big moment, maybe add a smile so they don’t think you’re rooting for disaster.

Butter someone up

Butter someone up
Image Credit: Sora Shimazaki via pexels

No actual butter is involved, though it does sound kind of pleasant. The saying may come from an ancient Indian tradition of throwing butter balls at statues of gods to gain favor.

Eventually, the concept evolved into showering someone with flattery to get what you want. So yes, complimenting your boss before asking for a day off still counts as a modern butter-ball offering.

Spill the beans

Spill the beans
Image Credit: Kaboompics.com via pexels

Imagine someone actually knocking over a pot of baked beans just to share a secret. Not exactly elegant, right?

This phrase likely dates back to ancient Greece, when people used beans to cast secret votes. Spilling them revealed the results early—hence, “spilling the beans” became code for letting a secret slip.

Kick the bucket

Kick the bucket
Image Credit: Kaboompics.com via pexels

It’s upbeat-sounding until you find out it’s about someone’s death. The most likely origin is from ancient English slaughterhouses, where beasts hung on a beam called a “bucket.” Spooky, right?

Cat got your tongue

Cat got your tongue
Image Credit: Edmond Dantès via pexels

Unless you’re starring in a cartoon, there’s no feline holding your tongue hostage. The phrase might come from old British punishments involving cat-o’-nine-tails whips or even from the ancient Egyptian fear of cats stealing souls.

Either way, it’s a colorful way to call out someone’s silence. But if a cat actually got your tongue, you’d have bigger problems than small talk.

Also on MSN: 17 Common Phrases That Reveal Someone Might Be Deeply Unhappy

It’s raining cats and dogs

It’s raining cats and dogs
Image Credit: jingoba via pixabay

Picture a storm where actual pets fall from the sky. Terrifying. The phrase probably comes from 17th-century England, where poor drainage during storms sometimes left dead animals in the streets.

Gruesome, yes, but memorable. Today, it just means “pouring rain,” though meteorologists would definitely prefer we use actual measurements.

Let the cat out of the bag

Let the cat out of the bag
Image Credit: Andrea Piacquadio via pexels

The image of a cat jumping out of a bag is hilarious—unless you’re the one holding it. This phrase dates back to medieval markets, where dishonest sellers might swap a piglet for a cat inside a sack.

If the cat got out, the scam was revealed. So next time you accidentally share someone’s surprise party plans, you’ve got centuries of history backing your slip-up.

Save this article

Enter your email address and we'll send it straight to your inbox.

Bite the bullet

Bite the bullet
Image Credit: ljsphotography via depositphotos

No one really wants to bite metal, but early firearms required biting paper cartridges to load gunpowder and musket balls. Soldiers had to do this calmly, even under enemy fire—symbolizing bravery in the face of danger.

Over time, “bite the bullet” evolved to mean “face something unpleasant with courage.” Still, most of us would rather bite into a chocolate bar than a bullet any day.

The whole nine yards

The whole nine yards
Image Credit: Pavel Danilyuk via pexels

Ask ten people what this means, and you’ll probably get ten different answers. Some say it refers to the nine yards of fabric in a World War II machine gun belt; others think it’s from tailoring or concrete mixing.

Whatever the origin, it’s become shorthand for “giving it your all.” Just don’t go looking for those literal nine yards—no one knows where they are.

Cold turkey

Cold turkey
Image Credit: Picas Joe via pexels

Quitting something “cold turkey” sounds strange—what does poultry have to do with willpower? Some say the term refers to the goosebumps and clammy skin that resemble cold turkey flesh when people go through withdrawal.

The phrase caught on in the early 1900s and stuck around ever since. It’s proof that English can make even quitting sound like a Thanksgiving side dish.

Beat around the bush

Beat around the bush
Image Credit: Christina Morillo via pexels

This one started in medieval England, when hunters literally beat around bushes to scare birds into flight for someone else to catch. Now, it means avoiding the main point in conversation.

It’s funny how the act of procrastinating on an answer has survived hundreds of years of linguistic evolution. So if someone asks you a tough question, try not to channel your inner medieval bird-beater.

Saved by the bell

Saved by the bell
Image Credit: SIphotography via depositphotos

No, not the ‘90s sitcom—this phrase predates Zack Morris by centuries. In old cemeteries, people were buried with strings tied to bells in case they were accidentally pronounced dead and woke up underground.

The bell ringing would literally “save” them. Thankfully, today’s version just means being rescued from a tough situation—like your phone ringing during an awkward meeting.

Key takeaways

Key takeaways
Image credit: bangoland via 123rf

English idioms sound crazy until you know their offbeat histories. Most of these expressions—such as “kick the bucket” or “spill the beans”—derive from centuries-old customs, superstitions, or literal habits that over time became metaphorical. Knowing the origin, even the most bizarre phrases begin to make a strange sort of sense.

These words are indicative of the way language evolves with humor and humanity. What began as black, utilitarian, or even ghastly words have become a part of everyday life to express emotion, advice, or encouragement. It is proof that English isn’t just a language—it’s a living family photo album of history, culture, and our shared imagination.

14 Things That Label You as ‘Uneducated’ on Social Media

Marekuliasz via Canva.com

14 Things That Label You as ‘Uneducated’ on Social Media

Welcome to the digital world, a place as intriguing as treacherous, where your online persona can instantly charm or alarm others. In this realm, your social media presence is your calling card, a digital mirror reflecting your thoughts, beliefs, and, perhaps, inadvertently, your level of education. Yet, fear not! This guide is here to help you navigate the vast ocean of social media with grace and wisdom.

15 Foods From the ’60s Most Boomers Loved With a Passion

Image Credit: mohamed abdelghaffar Via Pexels

15 Foods From the ’60s Most Boomers Loved With a Passion

The 1960s were a period of profound social and cultural transformation in America. As the baby boomer generation came of age, they embraced new ideas, fashion trends, and music styles. And when it came to food, some beloved dishes defined this era.