Larry David has turned awkward confrontations into comedy for decades. But one real-life clash still stands out.
“I have lots of confrontations on my show but rarely in life,” David said while reflecting on his fallout with longtime friend Alan Dershowitz. “And then only if I think I can take them in a fight. Hence the Dershowitz dust-up.”
The Curb Your Enthusiasm creator’s unusually personal comments have reopened a years-old friendship breakup that began after Dershowitz joined Donald Trump’s legal team during the president’s first impeachment trial.
David said Dershowitz’s decision changed their relationship permanently, telling The Atlantic that the former Harvard law professor “made a deal with the devil.”
“He only has himself to blame,” David said. “He made a deal with the devil. Literally.”
The “Dershowitz Dust-Up” That Ended a Longtime Friendship
For years, David and Dershowitz were unlikely but genuine friends.
According to The Atlantic, the two men regularly spent time together, shared meals, and had a relationship that went beyond casual acquaintance. Dershowitz said David used his gym and that he had helped him on various occasions.
That friendship changed after Dershowitz became one of Trump’s lawyers during the Senate impeachment trial in 2020.
Dershowitz was one of the lawyers who argued before the Senate that the allegations against Trump did not meet the constitutional standard required for removal from office. His argument focused on impeachment law and the meaning of “high Crimes and Misdemeanors.”
The Senate later acquitted Trump on both impeachment charges.
For David, however, Dershowitz’s involvement crossed a personal line.
In his comments to The Atlantic, David connected the friendship breakup directly to that decision. “I’d bet the devil hasn’t said a word to him since the impeachment,” he added.
David’s comments were a personal political criticism, not a legal assessment of Dershowitz’s work. Dershowitz has repeatedly argued that his role was based on a belief that anyone facing a constitutional proceeding deserves legal representation.
The Martha’s Vineyard Confrontation Became a Pop Culture Moment
The dispute became public in 2021 after David and Dershowitz crossed paths at the Chilmark General Store on Martha’s Vineyard.
The encounter quickly attracted attention because it involved two highly recognizable figures from completely different worlds: a comedian famous for fictional awkward confrontations and a lawyer who had become a central figure in Trump’s impeachment defense.
According to reports at the time, Dershowitz said David confronted him over his political associations, including his relationship with former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo.
Save this article
Enter your email address and we'll send it straight to your inbox.
Dershowitz later confirmed the argument happened, describing it as a heated exchange rather than the kind of comedic confrontation fans might expect from Curb Your Enthusiasm.
“Larry might not like it, but we can discuss it,” Dershowitz said after the incident. “Instead he just yelled and screamed at me in front of everybody.”
The exact details of the exchange came primarily from witness accounts and Dershowitz’s own description. No recording of the confrontation has been made public.
David Admits He Regrets One Part of the Fallout
Despite his continued criticism, David acknowledged that the situation was more complicated than a political disagreement.
During the interview, he admitted he should have reached out to Dershowitz after the death of Dershowitz’s son, Elon, who died last year at age 64 after a stroke.
“He’s 100 percent right,” David said. “I should have reached out, and I certainly regret not doing so.”
That admission added a more personal layer to a feud that has mostly been defined by politics and public disagreements.
David’s regret, however, did not change his view of the decision that caused the split.
He expressed sympathy over the loss but maintained that Dershowitz’s choice to defend Trump was the moment that changed their friendship.
Dershowitz Says the Rift Is Still Unresolved
Dershowitz told The Atlantic that the relationship has never recovered.
“Larry David doesn’t talk to me anymore,” he said. “He screams and yells at me when he sees me.”
The current reporting does not document a new confrontation between the two men or provide details of a recent encounter. Dershowitz’s comments describe his view of their current relationship.
For David, the story remains a rare example of life imitating his comedy.
The man behind some of television’s most famous fictional arguments found himself at the center of a very real one, sparked by politics, friendship, and a disagreement that neither side appears ready to forget.
And in classic Larry David fashion, even the fallout itself became part of the story.
Was Larry David right to draw a line over Dershowitz’s decision to defend Trump, or did the friendship deserve another chance?
