Will Enzyme Supplementation Help With Gas and Bloating?
As an Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) sufferer, you may have tried just about every possible combination of food, beverage and supplements, hoping for relief.
You may have heard of or read about digestive enzymes and wondered if they can help you. But, randomly trying yet another supplement and hoping for the best can be a painful road to travel.
So, what’s a bloaty, gassy person to do? Behold: Your primer on digestive enzymes and IBS!
What Are Digestive Enzymes?
Most individuals (more on this later) produce a variety of enzymes in their digestive tract that help them to digest the food they eat.
For example, the saliva produced in your mouth contains an enzyme called amylase, which starts to break down starch into simple sugars as you chew your food.
Further on down the line, your stomach produces the enzymes pepsin and gastric lipase, which help to break down protein and fat into smaller components that can be absorbed by your small intestine.
Your pancreas also produces a number of additional digestive enzymes that further help break the foods you eat into smaller parts that can be absorbed and turned into fuel for your body and its daily activities.
What Happens If You Don’t Have Enough Digestive Enzymes?
Individuals who do not produce sufficient amounts of digestive enzymes may have difficulties digesting certain foods, and thus, encounter painful symptoms of malabsorption that can come from large food molecules entering the large intestine undigested.
This is where gas and bloating can arise, as well as diarrhea. For example, many individuals of Asian, African or Latin American descent may lack the enzyme required (lactase) to break down the lactose found in dairy products[1].
Individuals with poorly managed celiac disease may also have problems digesting lactose as a result of damage to their intestinal villi, which normally produce lactase. Other individuals who have pancreatic or gall bladder disease may also suffer from digestive issues related to deficiency of important digestive enzymes.
Finally, some individuals with hereditary or genetic mutations may also lack or have very limited production of certain digestive enzymes.
You May Want To Read: What Conventional Wisdom Gets Wrong About Bloating
The Connection Between IBS & Digestive Enzymes
Many individuals with IBS also have some of the conditions mentioned previously, which then limits their ability to digest certain types of food. And others may genetically lack sufficient enzymes to digest one or more of the FODMAP groups, paving the way for a possible treatment via supplementation with digestive enzymes.
Let’s take a look at what enzymes are available and how they might be used.
- Lactase (B-galactosidase): This enzyme helps break down lactose (the “D” in FODMAPs) into its component sugars; glucose and galactose, and thus helps improve digestibility and absorption.
- Alpha-galactosidase: This is an enzyme that helps break down certain oligosaccharides (the “O” in FODMAPs). It tends to be most active in breaking down raffinose and stachyose, galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS) found in beans, peas, cabbage, some whole grains, broccoli and some other vegetables. Our bodies do not make alpha-galactosidase as a digestive enzyme, which is why GOS particles move to the large intestine undigested and cause gas and bloating, even in healthy individuals.
- Xylose Isomerase: Another enzyme that isn’t produced by the human body, this enzyme can help break down fructose into glucose, which can improve digestion and absorption of the “D” (for disaccharide) in FODMAPs.
- Pancrealipase: This enzyme breaks down dietary fat into smaller particles. It is important to note that fat is not a FODMAP, however some IBS sufferers do struggle with digestion of high fat meals.
| Enzyme/Product | What To Take | Where To Buy | How To Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| alpha-Galactosidase | Beano is a common supplements of this type in the U.S. *Beano caplets contain mannitol and/or sorbitol. Read labels carefully! | Beano and other alpha-galactosidase supplements are available via Amazon or other pharmaceutical retailers. | Look for a supplement that contains 300 GALU. Take one caplet with the first bites of your meal that contains GOS. |
| Lactase | Lactase enzyme supplements are commonly available in caplets and drops (and is already added to lactose-free dairy products). *Lactaid original strength caplets contain mannitol. Avoid this product if you are sensitive to this FODMAP or choose the Lactaid Fast Act caplets instead. | Widely available in pharmacies, some grocery stores and online retailers. | Take 1-3 tablets per meal or add 5-15 drops to one liter of milk and refrigerate for 24 hours before using. Adjust to your own personal tolerance levels |
| Xylose Isomerase | Xylosolv and Fructosin are two brand names of XI, but this supplement is not widely available in the U.S., except mixed with other enzymes, which may contain added pre- and probiotics. *Read labels carefully to avoid high FODMAP ingredients. | Check for online retailers and/or ask your pharmacy. | Take 1-2 capsules with liquid before high fructose-containing meals. |
You May Want To Read: All About Disaccharides
But Do They Work?
While many companies market digestive enzyme products, there is still fairly limited evidence regarding their effectiveness. Let’s take a look at the latest scientific data on this front.
- A 2017 study by Tuck et al[2] found that in GOS-sensitive IBS patients, alpha-galactosidase (AG) supplementation led to a significant reduction in abdominal pain, bloating and overall IBS symptoms, while a 2015 study by Finnish researchers[3] wasn’t as positive.
This older study concluded that while there was a trend toward reduced symptoms with the AG supplementation, there wasn’t a significant enough effect to recommend regular supplementation. So, what to do?
In this case, individuals who know that they are GOS-sensitive may want to trial supplementation of AG to see if it helps reduce symptoms. Supplementation with this enzyme may also be useful for individuals who follow a vegan or vegetarian version of the low FODMAP diet and have a high intake of beans and starchy or cruciferous vegetables.
- There is not a lot of recent evidence regarding the efficacy of xylose isomerase (XI) supplementation and IBS symptoms, however a 2012 study[4] evaluated changes in hydrogen production (which results from fructose malabsorption) between two study groups.
One group took a placebo, and another took XI. Each group ingested a relatively large dose of fructose and then completed hydrogen breath tests at 0, 30, 60, 120, 180 and 240 minutes. The group that took the XI showed lower production of hydrogen and reduced symptoms of abdominal pain, bloating and nausea, which is promising.
However, it is important to note that these patients had only very mild symptoms at baseline, so for individuals who are very sensitive to excess fructose, supplementation of XI may not be useful.
- Pancreatic lipase was studied in a small 2010 pilot study[5] on post-meal IBS-D (IBS with diarrhea), where it was found useful in reducing symptoms of cramping, bloating, pain and urge to defecate, while increasing stool firmness.
This particular study was sponsored by a pharmaceutical company, which provided the pancrealipase for study participants. Another recent study by Nishiyama et al[6] showed that supplementation of pancreatic lipase in mice increased the quantity of a key beneficial bacteria in the intestinal tract, however it has not been studied in humans. Thus, the data is somewhat unclear.
- Lactase supplementation has been studied and used for decades, and has been proven to be helpful for individuals with mild to moderate lactose intolerance. Supplementation does not always eliminate (convert) 100% of the lactose, so individuals who are extremely lactose sensitive may wish to avoid all naturally occurring lactose-containing products and/or choose products that are clearly labeled “lactose free.”
The Bottom Line
Digestive enzymes may be a helpful tool in your IBS-fighting arsenal, but they are not a cure-all and will not replace a well-structured low FODMAP diet and the advice of your doctor or dietitian.
References
[1] Emedicine.medscape.com. (2018). Lactose Intolerance: Background, Pathophysiology, Etiology. [online] Available at: https://emedicine.medscape.com/article/187249-overview#a6 [Accessed 1 Mar. 2018].
[2] Tuck, C., Taylor, K., Gibson, P., Barrett, J. and Muir, J. (2018). Increasing Symptoms in Irritable Bowel Symptoms With Ingestion of Galacto-Oligosaccharides Are Mitigated by α-Galactosidase Treatment.
[3] Markku Hillilä, Martti A. Färkkilä, Taina Sipponen, Janne Rajala & Jari Koskenpato (2015) Does oral α-galactosidase relieve irritable bowel symptoms?, Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology, 51:1, 16-21, DOI: 10.3109/00365521.2015.1063156
[4] Komericki, P., Akkilic-Materna, M., Strimitzer, T., Weyermair, K., Hammer, H. F. and Aberer, W. (2012), Oral xylose isomerase decreases breath hydrogen excretion and improves gastrointestinal symptoms in fructose malabsorption – a double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Aliment Pharmacol Ther, 36: 980–987. doi:10.1111/apt.12057
[5] Money ME, Walkowiak J, Virgilio C, et al. Pilot study: a randomised, double blind, placebo controlled trial of pancrealipase for the treatment of postprandial irritable bowel syndrome-diarrhoea, Frontline Gastroenterology 2011;2:48-56.
[6] Nishiyama H, e. (2018). Supplementation of pancreatic digestive enzymes alters the composition of intestinal microbiota in mice. – PubMed – NCBI. [online] Ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. Available at: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29106956
Finally a comprehensive breakdown of the enzyme FODMAP maze with science!!
Thank you!
I have found that the Eat Anything RX digestive enzyme, available on Amazon, works perfectly in fructose and lactose digestion. The manufacturer claims that it also helps digest legumes but have not tried it yet for this purpose.
The digestive enzyme Lypo Gold, manufactured by Enzymedica and also available on Amazon, works perfectly in fat digestion at 1/20th the cost of Zenpep, a prescription drug recommended by my gastroenterologist.
Hello Carol! Thank you for writing. We will forward this to the author, Diana, and have her respond.
Dédé
Can’t seem to get this in England -any tips?
What kind of enzyme are you looking for in particular? What symptoms are you addressing?
Thanks for the great suggestion for the Eat Anything RX supplement Carol! It does look like it has enzymes for lactose, excess fructose and galacto-oligosaccharides. The dose to take will depend on which FODMAPs you are most sensitive to. Some individuals may not need all 3 enzymes in one supplement, depending on FODMAP tolerance/sensitivity, so a single enzyme supplement may work better for those individuals.
The other supplement you mentioned contains enzymes that haven’t necessarily been scientifically tested specifically for IBS. They may help some individuals, but may not be useful for others.
As always, it’s best to speak to your doctor or dietitian before taking a new supplement.
Hello and thank you SO much for this article!!! Wish I had had this info years ago. Question though: why put mannitol in Beano when we cannot manage it for IBS? Why not just sugar or Stevia that would not be dangerous to us? Now in saying that, I have been on Beano for two weeks and have not had any D at all!! This is a record for me and I’m enjoying eating more food. I’m on a modified lofo diet (from my GI and RD) but still had symptoms every week and daily nausea. All those symptoms are greatly reduced or gone!! .
Hi Angela, we are so happy that the article was helpful! As you read, different supplementation is geared at various digestive complaints – not all of them FODMAP related, hence mannitol cropping up. BUT the great news is that you are finding your way! Here is to your continued digestive success!
Hello. I am having a difficult time determining what might be causing my unremitting bloating. One of the reasons for this might be because I have no other symptoms, none. Even when I am not in a cycle of severe bloating, I always seem, however, to be somewhat bloated no matter what I eat. I have tried excluding foods that might bloat me from my diet, to avail. I exercise and eat only whole foods; no sugar and no junk. If someone could be kind enough to offer some insight on this problem, I would greatly appreciate it, as I have just about exhausted all avenues open to me. I have tried consulting with doctors, but they know close to nothing about my problem because I have no other symptoms. I am going to try supplementation with digestive enzymes and see if I can reduce the severity of this cycle. Good luck to all of you out there in achieving what we are all striving for: stomach health!
Hi Andres, I am so sorry you are going through this – but know you are not alone. It is not unusual for doctors, even gastroenterologists to not be the best at working with patients to get to root issues. However, Registered Dietitians ARE FANTASTIC at this and one of the reasons we see people achieving success when they work with a RD, as opposed to when they don’t. Also, BTW, it is not recommended that you necessarily dive in with supplementation until you get medical, such as that from a RD. You might take a look at our article that discusses the difference between Dietitians and Nutritionists and also our article on Tamara Duker Freuman, who is affectionately referred to as The Bloated Belly Whisperer. Her book is Amazing and focuses on bloating.
Hello. The article notes that alpha-galactosidase and xylose isomerase are not produced by our bodies. 1) Are these a natural component of any foods, and if so, which? If not, what research as been done regarding their safety? 2) The article doesn’t say whether our bodies produce pancrealipase. Please clarify, and if we don’t, I have the same question about safety research regarding pancrealipase.
On a separate matter, I am hoping that manufacturers catering to people who need low-fodmap products will start offering enzymes and other products that are low-fodmap friendly by leaving out mannitol and other known triggers.
I recently discovered your site. It’s GREAT! Thank you!
Hi Ann. The RD who wrote the article is on break and we will get back to you as soon as we can. Thank you for writing and we are so glad you have joined our community.